Years ago, I found myself in the same room as Chris Martin—the frontman of Coldplay. He was sitting cross-legged on an enormous L-shaped couch, plucking away at an acoustic guitar while singing quietly to himself under his breath.
Judging by the expression on his face—one Jane Austen might describe as a “quizzical brow”—I assumed it was a song he had not played before.
Lost in thought, he reminded me of a fisherman who had felt the faintest nibble on the end of his line and was waiting, patiently, for whatever hummed beneath the surface to take the bait, so he could set the hook and reel it in.
I’ve always thought the creative process was something akin to fishing. I’m certainly not alone in this sentiment. The late, great filmmaker David Lynch literally wrote a book titled Catching the Big Fish. In the opening passage Lynch writes…
“Ideas are like fish. If you want to catch little fish, you can stay in the shallow water. But if you want to catch the big fish, you’ve got to go deeper. Down deep, the fish are more powerful and more pure. They’re huge and abstract. And they’re very beautiful. I look for a certain kind of fish that is important to me, one that can translate to cinema. But there are all kinds of fish swimming down there.”
We will return to Martin momentarily.
But, I don’t want to lose this thread—or line rather.
I’ve long suspected those who make a living from their creativity know, deep down, the ideas don’t come entirely from them.
John Prine rarely claimed to have written a song. His wife, Fiona, once told me that he preferred a different word. Catch.
He shared a wonderful songwriting ritual with Pat McLaughlin. They would write on Tuesday mornings, hoping to catch a song before Arnold's—a legendary meat and three here in Nashville—began serving meatloaf.
There is another story I adore about Michael Jackson.
Back in 2009, while Jackson was preparing for the This Is It comeback tour, he suffered bouts of insomnia. He was so overwhelmed with new, ambitious ideas for the already extraordinary production that he struggled to sleep.
Kenny Ortega, the creative director of the tour, was becoming overwhelmed.
Jackson explained to Ortega that God was sending him ideas in the middle of the night. He felt he had to do something with them.
Ortega joked that he wished God would take a vacation.
To which Jackson cheekily responded…
“You don’t understand—if I’m not there to receive these ideas, God might give them to Prince.”
Perhaps Jackson believed that he and Prince were fishing the same pond.
But, let’s return to Martin.
I thought it was such a gift to observe him fishing.
While hundreds of millions of people all around the world had watched him perform the songs he had caught, I wondered how many had the opportunity to watch him in the process of catching them.
I let him be.
Not entirely out of respect for his creative process. I’m terribly—at times cripplingly—shy. It’s pathetic, really.
If I ever suffered a heart attack at a gathering, I would set down my glass, walk to the bathroom, lock the door and die—as opposed to making a scene.
This is true whether I’m in a room filled with strangers, stars or strangers who are stars. I was never meant to be the centerpiece of the party; a chandelier. It wasn’t until my thirties I finally accepted that I’m destined to live out my days as a wallflower.
I prefer it this way.
This is why I found it so surprising when Martin set down his guitar, stood up, walked over to me and peppered me with questions.
What is your name?
Cole, you say?
What do you do for a living, Cole?
That’s interesting. Why do you do it?
Does it excite you, Cole?
That’s all anyone can ask for. Isn’t it?
Where is it you’re from, Cole?
What was it like growing up in Indiana?
Martin has this endearing British accent and this agreeable habit of placing your name at the end of the questions he asks you. At first, I thought it was strictly for show—and it very well might have been.
However, the following night, when we grabbed dinner with him and the woman he was seeing at the time, he remembered every single thing I told him. He even arrived with follow-up questions. He didn’t just do this with me, but with everyone who was in attendance the night prior.
It was stunning.
Daniel Tashian, a songwriter I deeply admire, once told me something I've returned to often…
“Interesting people are interested.”
Martin seemed to embody this mantra.
Maybe the secret to making interesting things—if there is such a thing—is taking a genuine interest in everything. Especially the people we might otherwise overlook.
I don’t remember the melody Martin was playing that evening. Perhaps I might recognize it on an album one day. But, I do remember the way he made me feel—as though I were the only person in the room.
Whenever possible, I try to return the favor.



Such good storytelling. Such truthhearing. I loved, “If I ever suffered a heart attack at a gathering, I would set down my glass, walk to the bathroom, lock the door and die—as opposed to making a scene.”
I was struck by a short monologue by David Lynch about catching ideas. I made a short video to accompany it.
https://youtu.be/B-fzDRxqBr0?is=tS7Hi_q8UZQ0omOn